> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.theinvestornarrative.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# The Three Private Markets: Which One Is Your Company Really In?
- URL: https://www.theinvestornarrative.com/three-private-markets/
- Published: 2026-11-10T15:29:55.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-10T15:31:13.000Z
- Description: Private-market liquidity is expanding, but not equally. The Trophy, Structured, and Thin Markets reveal how buyer demand shapes shareholder liquidity, valuations, and exit options for founders, boards, and investors.
- Author: Tom Krutilek
- Tags: Lead Analysis

*Private-market liquidity is expanding, but not evenly. For founders, boards, and investors, understanding where a company stands helps clarify which shareholder liquidity options are realistic, what buyers might pay, and which exit paths remain open.*

The growth in private-company share transactions is significant. On Nasdaq Private Market, the value of company-organized secondary transactions *more than tripled*, from $4.1 billion in 2023 to $13.2 billion in 2025\. Yet that growth has not translated into the same opportunities for every company or its shareholders.

Some private companies attract persistent interest from investors eager to buy their shares. Others can arrange shareholder sales when a transaction is organized around an acceptable price and willing buyers. Many more face limited demand, even when their underlying businesses remain sound.

A company's historical valuation does not necessarily reflect what buyers would pay today—or whether shareholders could find buyers at all.

This article focuses on liquidity for existing shareholders of venture- and growth-backed companies, rather than the broader ways companies raise capital or sell businesses. It introduces a *practical framework* to help founders, boards, and investors assess where buyer demand exists and which shareholder liquidity options may be realistic, recognizing that their responsibilities and ability to act will differ.

## **In brief**

- **Not every private company has the same access to liquidity.** Three broad environments help explain the differences: a *Trophy Market* with persistent buyer demand, a *Structured Market* where liquidity requires an organized transaction, and a *Thin Market* with limited natural buyers.
- **Current buyer demand matters more than a historical valuation.** A company's last financing valuation does not establish what investors would pay today. Its operating performance, growth prospects, sector, and available buyers all influence the outcome.
- **The goal is to identify realistic options, not rank companies.** These three markets do not measure business quality. They help founders, boards, and investors assess the opportunities and limitations of shareholder liquidity.

*This is the second article in a series on the fast-changing private capital market. The first,* [*The Fast-Changing Private Capital Market: More Options, Harder Choices*](https://www.theinvestornarrative.com/private-capital-market-more-options-harder-choices/)*, examined the expanding range of financing, liquidity, and exit options. The next article will explore whether a particular liquidity transaction solves a problem or simply buys time.*

---

## **Three Private Markets, One Spectrum**

The three-market framework examines shareholder liquidity through a practical question: if existing shareholders wanted to sell some of their shares, who would buy them, under what conditions, and at what price?

Three broad environments help answer that question. They are defined less by company size than by the depth of buyer demand and how liquidity becomes available.

The *Trophy Market* attracts persistent buyer interest. The *Structured Market* can support liquidity when a transaction is organized. The *Thin Market* has limited natural buyer demand, particularly at prices existing shareholders are willing to accept.

These are not formal industry classifications or rankings of company quality. They are points on a spectrum, and companies can move between them as their circumstances and investor demand change.

![Comparison table of three private markets—Trophy, Structured, and Thin—showing differences in buyer demand, shareholder liquidity, pricing evidence, and leadership decisions. ](https://storage.ghost.io/c/cb/6f/cb6ffcb0-463e-4f7a-b726-8a6a6bfe065e/content/images/2026/11/data-src-image-a4eac6f2-32ff-49d2-b0c1-d9740e119541.png)

An important distinction applies: the market for existing shares is not necessarily the market for acquiring an entire company. A business with limited interest in minority-share purchases may still attract an acquirer, while a company with active secondary trading may struggle to find a buyer for the entire business at an acceptable price.

Recent market activity illustrates how uneven liquidity opportunities have become.

In the third quarter of 2026, SpaceX's acquisition of [Cursor's](https://cursor.com/?ref=theinvestornarrative.com) parent company, [Anysphere](https://anysphere.inc/?ref=theinvestornarrative.com), accounted for more than half of all reported US venture exit value for the quarter. That extraordinary transaction illustrates how a small number of large deals can dominate overall exit activity, without necessarily improving liquidity opportunities for other private companies.

The market for existing shares shows a similar concentration. *Secondary trading*—where existing shareholders sell shares to other investors rather than the company issuing new shares—remains heavily concentrated among a relatively small group of companies. According to PitchBook, the 20 most actively traded companies on [Clarity](https://www.clarity.com/?ref=theinvestornarrative.com) (formerly Hiive) accounted for 86% of the platform's secondary trading value in the second quarter of 2026.

Pricing also varies sharply. [Forge](https://forgeglobal.com/?ref=theinvestornarrative.com) data cited by PitchBook showed that companies whose last financing occurred in 2026 traded at a median discount of approximately zero to their last financing valuation. For companies last financed in 2021, the median discount approached 60%.

The age of a company's last financing round does not, by itself, explain these pricing differences. Older valuations may reflect business performance or market expectations that have since changed. And because these figures cover only companies with observable secondary trading, they tell us little about companies whose shares have no active market.

Together, these findings reinforce the importance of current buyer demand rather than historical valuations. Understanding where a company stands is therefore the starting point for evaluating which liquidity options are realistic.

> ***A company's last valuation reflects a past financing. It does not establish what buyers would pay today.***

## **The Trophy Market: When Buyers Seek You Out**

Companies in the *Trophy Market* have what most private companies do not: persistent buyer demand. [Stripe](https://stripe.com/?ref=theinvestornarrative.com), [Databricks](https://www.databricks.com/?ref=theinvestornarrative.com), and [Anduril](https://www.anduril.com/?ref=theinvestornarrative.com) are examples of companies PitchBook identifies as potential leading names in the secondary market.

These companies can attract institutional investors, recurring tender offers, and active secondary trading, providing more frequent indications of what buyers are willing to pay. Demand reflects expectations for future growth, competitive positioning, and the prospect of an eventual exit.

Investor interest can also reflect factors beyond financial performance. [Anas Rafi](https://www.linkedin.com/in/anas-rafi-8b337213/?ref=theinvestornarrative.com) of [Mint Digital](https://mintdigital.vc/?ref=theinvestornarrative.com) observes that, among some high-net-worth individual investors, “company visibility and the appeal of investing in recognizable private companies can carry substantial weight in investment decisions.”

For these companies, the main question is often one of control: *who can buy and sell shares, through which arrangements, and how much trading should be permitted?* PitchBook notes that Anthropic, OpenAI, and Anduril have reinforced requirements for company or board approval before shares can be transferred. Strong buyer demand therefore does not mean every shareholder can sell.

The companies attracting the most attention will change as major private businesses go public or are acquired. But the defining characteristic of the Trophy Market remains the same: *investors actively seek access to shares, while companies retain significant influence over how that access is granted.*

## **The Structured Market: When Liquidity Has to Be Organized**

Companies in the *Structured Market* may not attract steady unsolicited demand for their shares, but they can find buyers when a transaction is organized around a credible business, an acceptable price, and clear terms.

[Clay](https://www.clay.com/?ref=theinvestornarrative.com) provides an example. In January 2026, the company announced its second employee tender offer in nine months, allowing eligible employees to sell up to $55 million in shares at a $5 billion valuation. A tender offer is an organized opportunity for eligible shareholders to sell some or all of their shares at a specified price. Clay's earlier tender, in May 2025, valued the company at $1.5 billion.

Organized liquidity is no longer limited to the largest private companies. According to [Carta](https://carta.com/?ref=theinvestornarrative.com), 71 tender offers totaling approximately $3 billion were administered on its platform in the first half of 2026\. While most involved later-stage businesses, smaller companies also participated. The median tender was approximately $28.5 million for companies at Series C and later, compared with $8.5 million for earlier-stage companies.

But these transactions remain selective. Companies able to organize successful tenders generally have credible investor demand already in place. Better transaction infrastructure makes shareholder liquidity easier to arrange; it does not create the buyers.

**Realistic options** include organizing a tender offer, arranging a secondary sale alongside a new financing, or waiting until the company has stronger operating results or clearer investor demand. In a combined transaction, the financing brings new capital into the company, while the secondary sale provides cash to existing shareholders who sell their shares.

These options also involve trade-offs. As [Gunderson Dettmer](https://catalyze.gunder.com/en?ref=theinvestornarrative.com) explains, organized liquidity transactions can require substantial management attention, sensitive financial disclosures, and decisions about which shareholders may participate. They can also affect employee stock-option valuations. Unlike new financing, the proceeds from secondary sales generally go to selling shareholders rather than the company.

The central question is therefore not simply whether a transaction can be organized. It is whether sufficient buyer demand exists at a supportable price—and whether providing liquidity serves the company's broader interests.

> ***You can organize a liquidity transaction. You cannot manufacture investor demand.***

## **The Thin Market: When Buyers Are Scarce**

The *Thin Market* describes companies whose shares attract limited buyer interest, particularly at prices existing shareholders are willing to accept. That describes the market for the shares, not necessarily the quality of the business.

"Most of them are not bad companies," [Isabelle Freidheim](https://www.linkedin.com/in/isabellefreidheim/?ref=theinvestornarrative.com), founder and managing partner of [Athena Capital](https://www.athenaspac.com/?ref=theinvestornarrative.com), told Carta of startups facing difficult exits. Many are profitable businesses whose growth has slowed below the expectations of venture investors.

Limited buyer demand should also be distinguished from restrictions on selling shares. A company may attract substantial investor interest while limiting which shareholders can sell. *In the Thin Market, the more fundamental problem is finding buyers at a price acceptable to sellers.*

The challenge is particularly evident among companies whose last financing occurred when valuations were substantially higher. Some have continued to build successful businesses, but investors may no longer be willing to pay prices based on earlier growth expectations.

[Airtable](https://www.airtable.com/?ref=theinvestornarrative.com) illustrates how far historical valuations and eventual outcomes can diverge. As discussed earlier, [Bending Spoons](https://bendingspoons.com/?ref=theinvestornarrative.com) acquired the company in 2026 at an equity value approximately 81% below its 2021 valuation. Airtable remained a substantial software business with meaningful recurring revenue and growth. [Miro](https://miro.com/?ref=theinvestornarrative.com) experienced a similar reset, with its acquisition by Bending Spoons completed at an equity value roughly 90% below its previous valuation.

Both examples illustrate how companies can overcome a challenge often associated with the Thin Market: finding a path to liquidity when buyers are unwilling to support historical valuations. Although Airtable and Miro were substantial businesses, completing an exit required accepting valuations well below earlier expectations.

A lower valuation can be painful for existing shareholders, but accepting a price supported by actual buyer demand can also make a transaction possible. *The question for a leadership team is whether accepting a current market price creates a better outcome than continuing to defend an old valuation.*

Realistic options include raising new capital at a revised valuation, negotiating a secondary sale for selected shareholders, preparing for an acquisition, combining with another company, or continuing to build toward stronger operating performance.

For many companies, an acquisition may offer a more realistic exit than a public listing. Startups on Carta completed 421 acquisitions in the first half of 2026, *a first-half record*. While that activity does not necessarily establish stronger demand for every company, it demonstrates that acquisition opportunities remain available even as secondary-market liquidity is uneven.

The objective is not simply to avoid a lower valuation. It is to understand which alternatives remain viable and which decision creates the best outcome for the company and its shareholders.

> ***A thin market isn't a verdict on the business. But it does change the options.***

## **Which Market Are You Really In?**

Leaders can overestimate their company's liquidity options, especially when a past valuation continues to shape expectations. A realistic assessment depends on current evidence: recent share transactions, credible buyer interest, and the price investors would be willing to pay today.

The following questions help identify where a company stands and which liquidity options may be available.

![Comparison table showing four questions to assess private-company shareholder liquidity across Trophy, Structured, and Thin Markets, including valuation evidence, buyer demand, organized share sales, and pricing.](https://storage.ghost.io/c/cb/6f/cb6ffcb0-463e-4f7a-b726-8a6a6bfe065e/content/images/2026/11/data-src-image-edd0e60e-b5a6-46af-8496-6b12e3b6f446.png)

These questions are a guide, not a scoring system. A company may fall between markets, and its position can change as operating performance, investor demand, or financing conditions evolve.

It is also important to distinguish demand for existing shares from interest in acquiring the entire company. A business with limited secondary-market liquidity may still attract a strategic buyer.

Understanding a company's liquidity market does not mean every shareholder can choose how or when to sell. Some transactions require company approval or management action, while others depend on shareholders finding willing buyers. The framework helps identify which options may be available, but the ability to pursue them depends on the shareholder's circumstances and the company's decisions.

*The purpose is not to assign a company to a permanent category. It is to establish a realistic starting point for decisions about financing, shareholder liquidity, and eventual exit. The most useful assessment is the one supported by evidence, not the one that produces the most favorable classification.*

## **The Same Question From Three Seats**

Founders, boards, and investors may agree on a company's operating performance yet reach different conclusions about its liquidity options. Their responsibilities, investment horizons, and economic interests are not necessarily the same.

**Founders and CEOs** must consider whether providing shareholder liquidity supports the company's broader interests, including retaining employees, managing ownership, and preserving capital for growth. They also need to be realistic about what opportunities can be offered to employees and early shareholders.

**Boards** should test management's assumptions about buyer demand, pricing, timing, and the alternatives available to the company. Their responsibility is to determine whether facilitating shareholder liquidity is appropriate and under what conditions, rather than simply accepting the last financing valuation as evidence of what the shares are worth.

**Investors who already own shares** need to distinguish a company's previous valuation from what they could receive by selling their investment today. Some may be able to find willing buyers, while others may depend on a company-organized transaction or eventual acquisition. Their ability to sell can also depend on company approval and other restrictions.

Financial outcomes can also differ among shareholders. Preferred shares often include *liquidation preferences*, which can give investors priority over common shareholders, including founders and employees, when sale proceeds are distributed. Depending on these rights and the transaction price, shareholders may receive very different returns from the same exit.

Disagreement among founders, boards, and investors is not necessarily a problem. It can expose differing assumptions about price, timing, and control before a transaction forces a decision.

## **Start With Where You Stand**

The expansion of private-market liquidity has not made every company more liquid. A transaction that works for one company may be impractical for another, and a historical valuation may no longer reflect what buyers are willing to pay.

Understanding which market a company operates in does not determine the right decision. *It clarifies which options are realistic.* For some companies, that may mean resetting valuation expectations, continuing to build, preparing for an acquisition, or deciding that shareholder liquidity should wait.

The goal is not to reach a higher category. It is to make better decisions based on the company's current position and the evidence of buyer demand.

The next article in this series examines whether a particular liquidity transaction solves a problem or simply buys time.

Until then, one question deserves an honest answer: **Which market would your board say your company is in—and would your next investor agree?**

#PrivateMarkets #PrivateCapital #VentureCapital #CorporateGovernance #Secondaries

---

## **References**

- [Cooley, Billy DuVal, Private Tender Offers and Secondary Transactions: Overview and Market Trends, February 24, 2026 (using Nasdaq Private Market transaction data).](https://www.sec.gov/files/sbcfac-webcast-022426-presentation-billy-duval.pdf?ref=theinvestornarrative.com)
- [Bending Spoons, "Bending Spoons has entered into a definitive agreement to acquire Airtable for $1.285 billion," August 4, 2026.](https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20260730994716/en/Bending-Spoons-has-entered-into-a-definitive-agreement-to-acquire-Airtable-for-%241.285-billion?ref=theinvestornarrative.com)
- [Bending Spoons, "Bending Spoons completes the acquisition of Airtable," September 4, 2026.](https://investors.bendingspoons.com/newsroom/bending-spoons-completes-acquisition-of-airtable?ref=theinvestornarrative.com)
- [Bending Spoons, "Bending Spoons enters into a definitive agreement to acquire Miro for $1.355 billion," September 10, 2026.](https://investors.bendingspoons.com/newsroom/bending-spoons-agrees-to-acquire-miro?ref=theinvestornarrative.com)
- [Bending Spoons, "Bending Spoons completes the acquisition of Miro," October 26, 2026.](https://investors.bendingspoons.com/newsroom/bending-spoons-completes-the-acquisition-of-miro?ref=theinvestornarrative.com)
- [Carta, "For startups seeking an exit in 2026, AI-powered growth is the difference between haves and have-nots," August 3, 2026.](https://carta.com/data/startup-exit-environment-h2-2026/?ref=theinvestornarrative.com)
- [Carta, "Tender-offer activity reaches a four-year high as startup liquidity needs continue to mount," August 20, 2026.](https://carta.com/data/tender-offer-update-h1-2026/?ref=theinvestornarrative.com)
- [Clarity, "From marketplace to market ecosystem: Hiive is now Clarity," September 22, 2026.](https://www.clarity.com/perspectives/hiive-is-now-clarity?ref=theinvestornarrative.com)
- [Clay, "Clay Announces Second Employee Tender Offer in Nine Months at a $5B Valuation," January 28, 2026.](https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20260128514638/en/Clay-Announces-Second-Employee-Tender-Offer-in-Nine-Months-at-a-%245B-Valuation?ref=theinvestornarrative.com)
- [Gunderson Dettmer, "Secondary Sales and Tender Offers," January 2, 2024.](https://catalyze.gunder.com/en/knowledge-hub/resource/secondary-sales-and-tender-offers?ref=theinvestornarrative.com)
- [Miro, "Miro raises $400M in Series C funding round to accelerate innovation through visual collaboration," January 5, 2022.](https://miro.com/newsroom/miro-series-c/?ref=theinvestornarrative.com)
- [PitchBook, "Q2 2026 US VC Secondary Market Watch," July 28, 2026.](https://pitchbook.brightspotcdn.com/a0/0f/51360d314d5892e70dca12e25c58/q2-2026-us-vc-secondary-market-watch.pdf?ref=theinvestornarrative.com)
- [PitchBook, "Q3 2026 US VC Secondary Market Watch," October 28, 2026.](https://pitchbook.com/news/reports/q3-2026-us-vc-secondary-market-watch?ref=theinvestornarrative.com)
- [PitchBook and National Venture Capital Association, "Q3 2026 PitchBook-NVCA Venture Monitor," October 7, 2026.](https://nvca.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/Q3-2026-PitchBook-NVCA-Venture-Monitor.pdf?ref=theinvestornarrative.com)
- [Silver Lake, "Announcing Airtable's Series F Funding," December 13, 2021.](https://www.silverlake.com/announcing-airtables-series-f-funding/?ref=theinvestornarrative.com)
- [SpaceX, Form 10-Q for the quarter ended September 30, 2026.](https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1181412/000162828026066880/spcx-20260930.htm?ref=theinvestornarrative.com)

## **About the Author**

*Tom Krutilek is a Board Advisor and Chief Marketing Officer who works with early-stage and growth-stage companies on capital readiness, investor narrative, go-to-market strategy, and AI strategy and governance. His work focuses on a central question: whether growth is truly investable—not just impressive on paper.*

*He helps founders, CEOs, and boards connect commercial performance, capital strategy, and execution to the evidence investors need to underwrite growth. That includes strengthening the investor narrative, identifying gaps in capital readiness, building measurable growth systems, and evaluating where AI can create durable business value and competitive advantage.*

*Tom is also the founder of The Investor Narrative, a publication focused on private capital markets from the perspective of investor readiness. It examines the questions behind the headline numbers—how investors assess growth, capital efficiency, demand quality, competitive advantage, governance, and the assumptions that ultimately determine whether a company is ready for investment capital.*

[Connect with Tom on LinkedIn](https://www.linkedin.com/in/tom-krutilek/?ref=theinvestornarrative.com)